- Josh L.
Best pizza in NY!!! I make my way out of the city just for a slice here. Highly recommended everything I get is amazing and full of flavor. Gone get a slice.
Been going there for years. The pizza is excellent. I really love their sauce. I don't know if they have trouble keeping a pizza maker, but it's very inconsistent. Some days the crust is too thick and doughy, sometimes it's very thin. Sometimes there's not enough cheese. Sometimes there's too much cheese, not enough sauce. But overall a good pizza. Friendly staff.
- Jim S.
So many great tasting slices here, but the humble plain slice is also superb, the sauce is just so tasty. Great ingredients make for great food, and everything here is always really fresh. Personal favorites are Chicken Alfredo, Margherita, and Grandma slices. Many fancy slices feature sesame seed crusts too, good to the last bite! Their chicken pops are also a favorite, as well as calzones. Great selection of soups too, pasta fagioli is another favorite! Yum yum! Best pizza in Greenlawn, if I'm rolling through Broadway it's really hard not to stop in for a slice!
Very solid pizza choice. If you like specialty slices, this is your place. My favorite is the chicken Alfredo. Holy cow! It's the best. Chicken bacon ranch. Grandma. Margarita. White. Even the Regular slice is great too, with a nice crispy crust. You can taste the difference in the higher quality ingredients.
First time ordering, Brocc. rabe and sausage pie. They were nice enough to stay a little late so i could pick up their pie after 9:30. Good pie, good toppings! Nice people, even better!! i will return
- Noor K.
I called to order a pizza, using a coupon from a local circular- it was $2.50 for a pizza. Wow, great price right?! We assumed that it was a promotion of some sort. I notified them that I had the coupon over the phone- and placed the order. When I got there, turns out it was supposed to be $2.50 off the large pie, they had made a typo- however this was not mentioned when I ordered the pizza over the phone, indicating that I had the coupon. Anyway, the manager refused to honor the clearly advertised price, like he should have done when mistakes happen. He actually became quite rude about it, stating that it was "common sense" that it wouldn't be that much. In any event, my husband wanting to avoid further discussion, paid the full price for the pizza, but we were both appalled by the lack of customer service displayed here.Moving on to the actual pizza- average at best. I'm probably biased based on the encounter, but it was nothing special, I could have gotten better pizza closer had I not been duped by their false advertising.Would not go back, and would definitely not recommend to others. If there was an option for 0 stars, they'd have it.
Honestly, this is probably the best pizza in Greenlawn, which makes this review even more of a bummer to write.Their grandma slices are great, and the Sicilian pizza is also really, really good. My fiancee is also a big fan of their Caesar salad slice - in fact, the variety of options there is really pretty mind-blowing. The dough is among my favorite, with a very homemade taste that reminds me a lot of my mother's. I'm really looking forward to trying the baked ziti and the chicken parmesan slices.So, why three stars and not the five that their pizza so richly deserves? Because while my experiences eating in have been stellar, takeout fell entirely flat. Not only was my slice cold (and I showed up just when they said to), it was lonely - I'd ordered and paid for two and got one. My fiancee's Caesar salad slice was equally disappointing, as we'd actually been given a Greek salad slice.So, if you order there and eat there, you'll have a great experience. Their accuracy leaves something to be desired however, and that really dragged things down.
Really good pizza. Best Panini I've ever had. My daughter had a Caesar salad with grilled chicken. It was really fresh and delicious. I just wish they had better air conditioning. It was really warm in there.
I was recommended to Broadway from my cousin who claims it's the "greatest pizza he's had" and to be quite frank, he's not that far off. The pizza is very good, and decently presented behind the counter. Out of the five slices (true story, five) I'd say my favorite was the Caesar salad slice. Although, the CBR (Chicken, Bacon, Ranch) slice was close, as was the deep dish slices. The Caesar with the well-done crust was the best salad slice I've had(Truth!). The buffalo was an average slice, which could've used more content to it(more cheese) still, though very appetizing. I would suggest speaking with the owner, Guy who is not only accommodating he is also a very customer service based individual who takes pride in making his customers satisfied. After commenting on the pizza he gave a smile, and thanked me for coming down! You cannot get service like that, least often. I highly suggest this establishment, And have brought its attention to my office so we now have a go-to pizza joint.I will be coming by more often, even though it is a drive.
- Samantha S.
Broadway pizza is a great choice. Their pizza is outstanding and customer service is great as well. Came in the other day for a slice of white pizza and they said they didn't have any made. One of the guys behind the counter told me that he will whip up a new pie for me. When I told him not to bother since I only needed a slice, he said he would make a personal white pizza for me. How awesome is that? They didn't know me, but were willing to do whatever they could to create a satisfied guest and they were definitely successful. The place is pretty small and only has seating for maybe 20 or so people. Their stuffed slices are ridiculously delicious.
It's always a toss up! Order from Jimmys or Broadway which is across the street!I'm from Queens NYC so I know what a real NYC slice is about, closest your gonna get in the suburbs of Long Island.I lean towards Broadway Pizza because their sauce is better on a simple cheese pie. They also have Zeppoles!
I'm REALLY not an "Everything is better in NY" snob, but..... PIZZA/Italian food in general = WORLDS apart!!! B'way Pizza is no exception!! Fresh, hot, and fast!! Came in for a "heading back to Ohio REAL PIZZA FIX" on a busy late Sunday afternoon. Wondered if not calling in ahead of time was a mistake, but our pizza was ready FAST, our spinach salad was great, and the guys behind the counter work like a well-oiled machine to get orders out quickly and smoothly!! EXTENSIVE menu of pizza, heros (NOT subs!!), wraps, and more. Catering menu looks great too!! As usual, I was wanting to order one of EVERYTHING on the menu, but had to save room/sanity/waist line for the trip back home to Ohhhhhio!! Take any random pizzeria on any corner or any drab strip mall, walk right in, order up a slice (or three...) of heaven on a plate, and think of me, lost in a sea of mediocre "pizza" wannabes here in Armpit, Ohioooo!! I'll be back...!!
- Roby N.
Best pizza in town! Friendly staff. They use fresh ingredients and it is evident when you enjoy the final product. They have great soups in the winter, and run specials for lunch as well as a few days a week. You will not be disappointed!
i eat here or get food delivered from here way too often lol. LOVE their margherita pizza, their garlic knots, Broadway salad, and heros. SO GOOD! you really cant' go wrong.
Let me say that after having the Primavera Pizza last night, I decided I must review this establishment!! It was fantastic! A nice crispy sesame crust nicely contrasted the peppery fresh tomato sauce, the meaty layer of lightly fried eggplant, which is hidden underneath a mound of beautiful fresh vegetables such as onion, broccoli, red pepper and cheese! Really, it was one of the best slices I've ever had- period! I've also had the white meatball pie and spinach pie and they are all amazingly tasty! I cannot comment on the heroes or entrees but I do plan on going back for those in the near future. That is part of the reason why I gave 4 out of 5 stars, along with a delivery fee of $3.00. No, it is not a lot of money but most places in the are offer free deliver so the charge here is worth noting.
- Mayra C.
This review is long over due! But we were really happy with the catering. I found out about Broadway catering thru an online search, was helping out my friend find an affordable caterer for her wedding. And Found this amazing place. Not only Guy helpful but the food was great! At the wedding everyone was happy with the menu. Thanks so much!
Our little town of Greenlawn has numerous dry cleaners, a few bars,a handful of restaurants, and two pizza places. Broadway Pizza so happens to be my favorite of the two places. Situated on Broadway-Greenlawn Ave, it's literally a 2 minute walk from my house. How awesome is that, really?I was just there earlier this afternoon for a couple slices before I went to the city for the day. I like the pizza at Broadway for several reasons: the sauce is crisp and sweet, the cheese is the right amount of gooeyness, and the crust has the right crunch for me. It's not an overly doughy crust like some places make, it's more of a thinner variety, brimming with texture and taste.There are many different pizza styles to choose from, but I'm either a plain cheese person or a pepperoni slice type of guy. And speaking of Guy, he's one of the nicest people you could meet. Guy is the owner of Broadway Pizza and a very personable and pleasant man. He has a really polite and friendly staff of younger people working for him, which is a plus for any business.I haven't tried any of the other offerings they serve, and they do have catering available, but as much as I like the pizza, I am sure I would like whatever else they make.The prices are reasonable, the service is quick, and it's a nice place to chill out with some slices and read the paper. If you like sports, ESPN is usually on the flat screen. There are also some really cool New York themed pictures and decorations on the walls.It's great to have such a decent place to get a pizza so close to home, and even greater that the place is pretty awesome.