Long Island Catering

For delicious Italian cuisine made with old-world recipes complemented by some delightful modern twists, choose Broadway Catering, a leading Long Island catering company with nearly two decades of experience and culinary expertise. We specialize in preparing a wide assortment of Italian food and pizza for a wide range of Nassau County and Suffolk County events, including wedding showers, graduations, family reunions, and more. Our catering service is committed to using the highest-quality fresh ingredients to create our classic Italian favorites and pizzeria specialties.

Conveniently located in Greenlawn, our Long Island catering service and restaurant serves a wide range of people, families, organizations–everybody who loves Italian food that brims with homemade goodness. As a popular pizzeria and Italian catering company for the region, we feed everyone from area baseball teams to business organizations. Our team of Long Island chefs is always happy to customize your order to suit your preferences. We make the ordering process a breeze. Just checkout our catering menu and packages to find options that meet your event’s needs.

Broadway Catering features an expansive menu of Italian food options and pizza. Our Long Island catering service menu includes delectable options such as Penne a la Vodka and other pasta favorites, Italian heroes, poultry and meat dishes, salads, seafood, and mouthwatering desserts like cannolis. Be sure to visit us for fast casual dining or make it a pizza night and order delivery or carryout. As a popular Long Island catering service, dine-in restaurant, and pizzeria, we’re committed to ensuring that every taste is delicioso!

Be sure to contact us to discuss your Suffolk County or Nassau County special event and let our chefs wow the crowd with their superior catering service. Call us to place your order or visit our Greenlawn location and come taste why we’re the number one Italian food destination on Long Island.

Contacts

60 Broadway Greenlawn,
Greenlawn, NY 11740
info@broadwaycatering.com
(631) 261-0828
our menu

Explore the Catering menu

Appetizers

Fresh Baked Stromboli

$30 Half Tray / $60 Full Tray

delicious sliced stuffed bread with choice of sausage, meatball, pepperoni, peppers, onions, broccoli, ham & spinach with mozzarella

Pepperoni in Blankets

$25 Half Tray/$45 Full Tray

Pizza Hors D’oeuvres

$28.00

sicilian pizza with assorted toppings cut into small pieces

Fried Zucchini

$40 Half Tray / $80 Full Tray

Grilled Shrimp Skewers

$5.95 each (minimum or 12)

marinated shrimp, skewered and grilled over mixed greens

Garlic Knots

$5.00/dozen

Mozzarella Sticks

$12.00/dozen

served with our marinara for dipping

Buffalo or BBQ Wings

$55 Half Tray / $100 Full Tray

served with crisp celery and choice of bleu cheese or ranch dressing

Chicken Skewers

$4.95 each (min. order is 12)

Grilled chicken, summer squash, suntan peppers, red onions and mushrooms

Pigs in Blankets

$45 Half Tray / $90 Full Tray

Seafood Stuffed Mushrooms

$60 Half Tray / $110 Full Tray

Buffalo Fried Calamari

$55 Half Tray / $95 Full Tray

Italian Style Chicken Fingers

$50 Half Tray / $100 Full Tray

choice of BBQ, Honey Dijon or Marinara

Shrimp Cocktail

$20.00/dozen

Served with lemon wedges and cocktail sauce

Pulled Pork Sliders

$65 Half Tray / $120 Full Tray

Baked Clams

$45 Half Tray / $90 Full Tray

Salads

Greek Salad

$40 Half Tray / $79 Full Tray

crisp iceberg & romaine with cucumbers, tomatoes, shredded carrots, pepperoncini, feta, red onion & kalamata olives

Baby Spinach Salad

$39 Half Tray / $77 Full Tray

red onion, shredded carrots, seeded tomatoes, dried cranberries, grilled pine nuts & our balsamic vinaigrette

Caesar Salad

$30 Half Tray / $60 Full Tray

romaine hearts, pecorino romano, golden croutons & our creamy caesar dressing

Caesar Salad w/Grilled Chicken

$45 Half Tray / $85 Full Tray

Tossed Garden Salad

$30 Half Tray / $59 Full Tray

iceberg & romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, shredded carrots & red onions

Tossed Garden Salad w/Grilled Chicken

$45 Half Tray / $80 Full Tray

Tossed Garden Salad w/Shredded Mozzarella

$40 Half Tray / $75 Full Tray

Mesculin Mixed Green Salad

$39 Half Tray / $77 Full Tray

colorful combo of mixed greens with tomatoes, cucumbers, dried cranberries, candied walnuts & bleu cheese crumbles with mango dressing

Tri-color Tortellini Salad

$45 Half Tray / $85 Full Tray

broccoli, diced sundried peppers, red onions and black olives in a olive oil and red wine vinaigrette

Vegetables & Sides

Long Grain White Rice

$20 Half Tray / $40 Full Tray

Mashed Potatoes or Garlic Mashed

$35 Half Tray / $65 Full Tray

Sauteed or Steamed Broccoli Spears

$35 Half Tray / $65 Full Tray

Fresh Grilled Vegetables

$48 Half Tray / $80 Full Tray

Garden Vegetables in Garlic & Oil

$40 Half Tray / $79 Full Tray

String Beans Almondine

$45 Half Tray / $85 Full Tray

Sauteed Zucchini

$35 Half Tray/$65 Full Tray

Broccoli Rabe w/ Garlic & Olive Oil

$40 Half Tray/$80 Full Tray

Roasted Rosemary Potatoes

$35 Half Tray / $65 Full Tray

Fresh Grilled Asparagus

$60 Half Tray / $120 Full Tray

Party Heroes

Hot Eggplant Parmigiana

$21.95/Foot

Hot Chicken Parmigiana

$21.95/Foot

Grilled Chicken

$21.95/Foot

Roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella and balsamic dressing

Grilled Vegetable

$21.95/Foot

Italian, American or Combo

$17.95/Foot

Pasta

Penne & Broccoli with Garlic and Oil

$40 Half Tray / $79 Full Tray

Rigatoni Marinara

$40 Half Tray / $79 Full Tray

Stuffed Shells

$45 Half Tray / $85 Full Tray

Penne ala Vodka

$48 Half Tray / $95 Full Tray

Penne ala Vodka w/Grilled Chicken

$59 Half Tray / $110 Full Tray

Tortellini Carbonara

$55 Half Tray / $105 Full Tray

Rigatoni Alfredo with Grilled Chicken Breast

$55 Half Tray / $105 Full Tray

Penne Pesto with Sundried Tomatoes & Broccoli

$50 Half Tray / $95 Full Tray

Penne Rustica

$55 Half Tray / $100 Full Tray

diced chicken, spinach & mozzarella in a pink tomato cream sauce

Baked Ziti

$40 Half Tray / $80 Full Tray

Meat or Vegetable Lasagna

$50 Half Tray / $95 Full Tray

Penne with Broccoli Rabe & Sausage

$50 Half Tray / $95 Full Tray

Farfalle with Chicken, Sausage, Potato, Peppers & Onions

$45 Half Tray / $85 Full Tray

Rigatoni with Chicken, Mushrooms, Fresh Tomato & Basil

$55 Half Tray / $100 Full Tray

Baked Ziti Sorrentino

$49 Half Tray / $95 Full Tray

baked ziti with lightly breaded eggplant

Pasta Primavera

$49 Half Tray / $95 Full Tray

Bowties

$55 Half Tray / $100 Full Tray

With chicken, sausage, potato, peppers and onions

Poultry & Meat

Chicken Sorrentino

$55 Half Tray / $105 Full Tray

Chicken Marsala

$55 Half Tray / $105 Full Tray

Chicken Scarpariello

$55 Half Tray / $105 Full Tray

Hawaiian Chicken

$55 Half Tray / $100 Full Tray

Chicken Francaise

$55 Half Tray / $100 Full Tray

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana

$50 Half Tray / $105 Full Tray

Meatballs Pomodoro

$52 Half Tray / $100 Full Tray

Veal Cutlet Parmigiana

$85 Half Tray / $160 Full Tray

Sausage & Peppers

$52 Half Tray / $95 Full Tray

Sausage Pomodoro

$52 Half Tray / $100 Full Tray

Honey Glazed Sliced Ham

$9.95/lb.

(weights slightly vary)

Veal Marsala

$85 Half Tray / $160 Full Tray

Platters

Bruschetta over Mozzarella & Garlic Toast

$45 Half Tray / $85 Full Tray

fresh mozzarella, roma tomatoes, basil & olive oil on herb toasted bread

Sandwich or Wrap Platter

$9.95 per person

variety of quality meats and cheeses on assorted breads, displayed on platters with mayo & mustard

Fresh Crudite Platter

$45 Half Tray / $90 Full Tray

assortment of fresh vegetables with your choice of blue cheese or creamy ranch dip

Cheese & Cracker Platter

$50 Half Tray / $95 Full Tray

assorted cubed cheeses with pepperoni and gourmet crackers

Antipasto Platter

$55 Half Tray / $105 Full Tray

assortment of quality Italian meats, cheeses and vegetables

Fresh Fruit Platter

$45 Half Tray / $85 Full Tray

a colorful and mouth watering medley of seasonal fruit

Cold Cut Platter

$60 Half Tray / $115 Full Tray

quality thinly sliced meats and cheeses rolled on a decorated platter

Caprese Platter

$40 Half Tray / $80 Full Tray

fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers & sliced tomato

Vegetarian

Eggplant Rollatini

$50 Half Tray / $95 Full Tray

Eggplant Parmigiana

$50 Half Tray / $95 Full Tray

Marinated & Grilled Vegetables

$48 Half Tray / $95 Full Tray

Seafood

Shrimp Francaise

$85 Half Tray / $160 Full Tray

Shrimp Fra Diavlo

$85 Half Tray / $160 Full Tray

Fried Calamari

$45 Half Tray / $85 Full Tray

Calamari Marinara

$49 Half Tray / $95 Full Tray

Mussels Blanco or Marinara

$45 Half Tray / $90 Full Tray

Seafood Supreme

$90 Half Tray / $175 Full Tray

with shrimp, clams, mussels, & calamari marinara

Desserts

Cannoli Platter (mini Cannolis)

$20.00/dozen

Platter of Fresh Seasonal Fruit

$45 Half Tray / $85 Full Tray

Gourmet Cookie Platter

$48.00/5lb. Tray

testimonials

Great pizza and takeout Italian food. Best eggplant parmigiana I’ve ever had. So good I don’t even make it at home anymore. Always a safe bet after a rough day when coming home to cook is not an option.

Stephen Taranovich

A good old fashioned hole in the wall with great food and huge portions. If you’re looking for classic style slices and sandwiches in Greenlawn, this is the perfect place.

Daniel straitiff

Amazing environment and very friendly service. The menu was crisp and delicious. Will definitely recommend this restaurant to my friends. Reasonable prices and large meals. Good job.

Armando R

They definitely have the best wings in town! The wings are decent size and not fatty at all! I also love their hot sauce as well. It’s super delicious. They taste so good when I order them from Off Broadway! Beside the awesome wings they have, they also make amazing pizzas and pastas as well. They have been around for while and the owner is super nice!! This place is highly recommended for sure.

Mark Wan

Our office always get’s food catered and we have never had anything that wasn’t amazing (And we have had just about everything on their catering menu). The food is hot and fresh, and their mini cannolis are a must! They’re always fresh, tasty and crunchy!

Kristy Falango
{"video_yurl":"true"}

RUSTIC ITALIAN CATERING

Phone

Online Reservations
(631) 261-0828

Address

60 Broadway Greenlawn,
Greenlawn, NY 11740

Hours of Operation

Monday to Thursday: 11 AM – 9:00 PM
Friday to Saturday: 11 AM – 10.00 PM
Sunday: 11 AM – 9:00 PM
ADA Compliance