Dine In

Suffolk County Pizzeria

When you’re craving pizza, choose Broadway Catering for our dine-in and carry-out pizzeria service. As the leading Greenlawn pizzeria, we use the freshest ingredients to create our delectable pizzas. Choose from our signature specialties or create your own custom pizza with your favorite ingredients. Our chefs specialize in Italian food, including gourmet pizza made with old-world goodness.

Broadway Catering may be the number-one Suffolk County Catering Service for Italian food, but we’re also a popular dine-in pizzeria based right here in Greenlawn. Visit us to celebrate a special occasion like an anniversary, date night, or to treat your family or good friends to the best Italian food and gourmet pizza on Long Island. We are the premier Nassau County catering service and Suffolk County pizzeria, so visit us to enjoy Italian fare that brims with the flavors of Naples, Calabria, Palermo, and Rome!

Our chefs feature:

  • Appetizers
  • Salads
  • Heroes
  • Pasta
  • Gluten Free and Vegan
  • Poultry and meat dishes
  • Seafood
  • Gourmet pizza
  • Dessert

We feature welcoming ambience that’s always complemented by our attentive staff and dedicated chefs. When you’re in the mood to dine at a Greenlawn pizzeria or have a craving for traditional Italian food, simply call to reserve your table or stop by for carry-out service as well. Our Suffolk County catering service also includes many of our most popular dishes, including pasta, hot heroes, meat and poultry dishes, seafood, salads, and, of course, pizza!

Broadway Catering invites you to find out why we’re everybody’s favorite Greenlawn pizzeria and Italian food restaurant on Long Island. Our chef-prepared Italian food will make your taste buds swoon for more. Not sure what to order? Come in for hot-from-the-oven stromboli, cheesy tortellini carbonara, or one of our delectable seafood dishes topped with fresh mussels and shrimp. Our chefs are always eager to serve you when you dine in or opt for off premise delivery with outstanding Suffolk County catering service. Call now to place your order.


Great pizza and takeout Italian food. Best eggplant parmigiana I’ve ever had. So good I don’t even make it at home anymore. Always a safe bet after a rough day when coming home to cook is not an option.

Stephen Taranovich

A good old fashioned hole in the wall with great food and huge portions. If you’re looking for classic style slices and sandwiches in Greenlawn, this is the perfect place.

Daniel straitiff

Amazing environment and very friendly service. The menu was crisp and delicious. Will definitely recommend this restaurant to my friends. Reasonable prices and large meals. Good job.

Armando R

They definitely have the best wings in town! The wings are decent size and not fatty at all! I also love their hot sauce as well. It’s super delicious. They taste so good when I order them from Off Broadway! Beside the awesome wings they have, they also make amazing pizzas and pastas as well. They have been around for while and the owner is super nice!! This place is highly recommended for sure.

Mark Wan

Our office always get’s food catered and we have never had anything that wasn’t amazing (And we have had just about everything on their catering menu). The food is hot and fresh, and their mini cannolis are a must! They’re always fresh, tasty and crunchy!

Kristy Falango
ADA Compliance