Who We Are

Long Island Italian Catering

Broadway Catering has been serving up delectable Italian food, pizza, heroes, salads, and more for more than 19 years. As a leading Long Island Italian catering service, we prepare our traditional and contemporary updates on popular favorite dishes for dine-in and carry-out customers as well as for special events such as company luncheons, graduation parties, family reunions, showers, and much more. Based in Greenlawn, our Off Premise Catering Service provides delectable Italian food for events throughout Suffolk County and Nassau County–always delicious and always for a fair price.

For authentic Italian pizzeria specialties and Italian food prepared with the freshest ingredients, choose Broadway Catering. Our chefs and staff are devoted to ensuring that every dish is perfect. We’ve been feeding Long Island for years and we are proud of our reputation for quality and top-notch customer service. We are enthusiastic about Italian food and love to share our specialties with crowds. For exceptional Italian catering service for your Suffolk County or Nassau County event, rely on Broadway Catering to delight every guest’s taste buds with our undeniably delicious fare!

Broadway Catering is ready to serve your Off-Premise Catering needs. Contact us to place an order for our catering service. Our team is flexible and we are often able to customize our Long Island Italian catering service to suit our customers’ needs.

We invite you to let our Italian food do all the talking! Visit Broadway Catering to enjoy an old-world favorite like our meat lasagne or Chicken Marsala. We feature a diverse range of culinary options to suit every taste. Our chefs offer vegetarian, vegan and gluten free-friendly dishes as well as seafood, meat, and poultry offerings. And don’t forget our pizzeria service! Long Islanders rave about our gourmet pizza topped by your choice of fresh ingredients. Call to place your order or visit us today.


Specialty and Rustic Italian-style cuisine with a wide variety of appetizing selections to choose from. It’s the best-tasting food made with the freshest ingredients at the most competitive prices. And we also offer beverage service.

Service That’s

We’ve got plenty of satisfied repeated customers that you can call as references. We have the rare quality being quick to return calls and emails as well as being open to critiques and new ideas.


Our chefs and kitchen staff understand how to elegantly and expertly surprise and delight your guests by delivering beautiful, tasty and adventurous food with great service that compliments your event theme.

Great pizza and takeout Italian food. Best eggplant parmigiana I’ve ever had. So good I don’t even make it at home anymore. Always a safe bet after a rough day when coming home to cook is not an option.

Stephen Taranovich

A good old fashioned hole in the wall with great food and huge portions. If you’re looking for classic style slices and sandwiches in Greenlawn, this is the perfect place.

Daniel straitiff

Amazing environment and very friendly service. The menu was crisp and delicious. Will definitely recommend this restaurant to my friends. Reasonable prices and large meals. Good job.

Armando R

They definitely have the best wings in town! The wings are decent size and not fatty at all! I also love their hot sauce as well. It’s super delicious. They taste so good when I order them from Off Broadway! Beside the awesome wings they have, they also make amazing pizzas and pastas as well. They have been around for while and the owner is super nice!! This place is highly recommended for sure.

Mark Wan

Our office always get’s food catered and we have never had anything that wasn’t amazing (And we have had just about everything on their catering menu). The food is hot and fresh, and their mini cannolis are a must! They’re always fresh, tasty and crunchy!

Kristy Falango
ADA Compliance